October Recap.
Third issue · November 2026. A monthly review of the Wisconsin Supreme Court—what the Court has just done, what is at stake, and where to read further. This issue recaps the arguments heard October 6, 8, and 13, reports the Court’s November 11 order returning Act 10 to its docket, previews the seven cases on the November calendar, and introduces Judge Emily Lonergan, newly appointed to the Court of Appeals, District III.
Click a page to zoom in and read; click it again to see the spread. Turn pages with the arrows, your keyboard, or a swipe.
Over three days in October, the Wisconsin Supreme Court heard seven arguments—the last two before a public audience at the Heyde Center in Chippewa Falls. The subjects had little in common: a hospital tower’s tax bill, a village’s ban on short-term rentals, a federal tax claim against a foreclosure surplus, a reckless-homicide jury instruction, an attorney discipline matter, a conservation warden’s roadside investigation, and a snowmobile trail through a state park. Yet the bench kept returning to the same two questions: what did the Legislature actually write, and how much have the courts added on top of it? Then, on November 11, the Court granted review in the challenge to Act 10 and put the law back on its own docket.
Back to the words
In the issue’s lead commentary, Kevin M. Zielinski traces how the justices kept questioning their own judge-made doctrine—the “readying rule” in Children’s Hospital, the six-factor zoning test in Wildwood—and pressed agencies on the limits of their statutory power. A shared vocabulary of text is welcome, he argues, but the real test comes when the text leads to an outcome a justice would not choose. Pages 1–2 →
Act 10 returns to the Court
On November 11 the Court granted the unions’ petition in Abbotsford Education Ass’n v. WERC, the challenge to 2011 Wisconsin Act 10. Justice Ziegler dissented from the grant; Justice Hagedorn, Governor Walker’s chief legal counsel when the law passed, did not participate. At issue is where Act 10 drew its public safety line, and which rational-basis framework governs a claim under the state equal protection guarantee. Briefing opens December 11; no argument date is set. Page 2 →
Six October arguments, reviewed
Whether Strickland prejudice can rest on a single jury note (Osornio); whether a tower 14 percent built is “used exclusively” as a hospital (Children’s Hospital); who collects first from a $54,421.96 foreclosure surplus, the IRS or the Department of Revenue (Estate of Nelson); whether a villagewide rental ban is zoning (Wildwood); whether a warden who may arrest may also investigate (Phelan); and whether agency discretion can erase a statutory right to a hearing (Blue Mound). Pages 3–5 →
Looking ahead: the November calendar
Seven cases on November 5, 10, 17, and 19—among them Abby Windows v. LIRC, which asks the Court whether to revisit Kalal and adopt a “holistic” approach to statutory interpretation, and Minority Business Association v. DATCP, on whether a business can challenge an administrative-search regime before it receives a demand. Page 6 →
New on the Court of Appeals
On November 2, Governor Evers appointed Outagamie County Circuit Judge Emily Lonergan to District III, filling the seat of retiring Presiding Judge Lisa Stark. The profile covers her record, her service on the three-judge panel that dismissed Bothfeld, and the 11 decisions in which District III has reviewed her rulings since 2019. Page 7 →
Contributors: Jake Curtis, Daniel Suhr, and Kevin Zielinski. Prefer to read offline? Download the full newsletter (PDF).