Overview
The Wisconsin Supreme Court heard argument on October 6, 2026, on whether a nonprofit hospital owes property tax on an addition that is still being built. On January 1, 2020, the assessment date, Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin’s North Tower in Wauwatosa was about 14 percent complete. The City assessed it, and the hospital paid a $122,870 tax bill under protest.
A divided court of appeals held that the “readying rule,” a nearly fifty-year-old doctrine that exempts property being readied for an exempt use, reaches only buildings that are fully constructed and in the final stages of preparation.1 The hospital asks the Court to reverse. At argument, several justices pointed toward a path neither side had briefed: whether the statute’s own words, property “used exclusively for the purposes of” a hospital, answer the question without a judge-made rule.
What You Should Know
Five things to carry into the decision
- Wis. Stat. § 70.11(4m) exempts property of a nonprofit hospital of ten or more beds that is “used exclusively for the purposes of” the hospital. Status is fixed each year on January 1, and exemptions are construed strictly, with the burden on the taxpayer.1
- The court of appeals affirmed summary judgment for the City, 2–1. The majority confined the readying rule to the facts of Family Hospital: a finished, equipped nursing home awaiting staff. The dissent would have remanded for fact-finding on whether the tower qualified during construction.
- The hospital asks for an outright reversal and judgment in its favor, arguing the undisputed record shows the tower could only have become a hospital. The City argues a building that does not yet exist cannot be “used” for anything.
- The City also asked the Court to retire three judge-made glosses: the “strict but reasonable” canon, the readying rule, and the “reasonable necessity” test. It argues all three conflict with the 1997 command in § 70.109 that exemptions be “strictly construed in all instances.”
- The bench pressed the City on its own past practice: it had not assessed other projects under construction, including others on the same medical campus, before a 2021 review of hospital exemptions.
Can an Unfinished Building Be “Used”?
The dispute is narrow on its face and wide underneath: twelve subsections of § 70.11 share the same operative language.
It could only have become a hospital
The readying rule covers property being prepared for an exempt use, and the undisputed record shows the tower was never going to be anything else. The statutory phrase “used exclusively for the purposes of” looks forward, and the Department of Revenue’s Assessment Manual recommends exempting new construction attached to an exempt hospital.
A building that does not exist cannot be used
Exemption status is fixed on January 1, exemptions are strictly construed in all instances under § 70.109, and the tower was not capable of being occupied. The three judge-made glosses should be retired as inconsistent with that command.
What Happened
The tower is an addition connected to the main hospital on the Milwaukee Regional Medical Complex. Click any step for detail.
Construction begins
On a parcel acquired from Milwaukee County. The hospital planned outpatient services, including hospital-based specialty clinics and surgical services.
The assessment date — 14 percent complete
The foundation and first-floor walls were up; the City’s assessor estimated the project at 14 percent complete.
Exemption denied; $122,870 bill
The hospital paid before suing in 2021.
Summary judgment for the City
Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Gwendolyn Connolly concluded the tower could not have been used exclusively for exempt purposes, and that the Department of Revenue’s Assessment Manual, which recommends exempting new construction attached to an exempt hospital, conflicts with the law.2
Court of appeals affirms, 2–1
Judge Colón held the readying rule applies only to a building “fully constructed and equipped, and in the final stages of readying itself for an exempt purpose” — a phrase from FH Healthcare. Then-Chief Judge White dissented and would have remanded for fact-finding.3
Before the Supreme Court, the hospital argues the decision misreads the readying rule, undercuts the public good of hospital services, and conflicts with the Assessment Manual. The City defends the decision on the statute’s plain language and the rule of strict construction. Review was granted on whether § 70.11(4m) and the readying rule exempt the incomplete tower.
Legal Background
Property tax is the rule and exemption the exception. The taxpayer must prove that its property fits squarely within a statutory exemption on the January 1 assessment date, and since 1997, § 70.109 has directed that exemptions be “strictly construed in all instances.” That statute arrived three decades after Columbia Hospital described the standard as “strict but reasonable.”
Columbia Hospital and Sisters of St. Mary read the hospital exemption’s “used exclusively for the purposes of” language to cover property reasonably necessary to a hospital’s functioning. In 1977, the Legislature amended § 70.11(4m) to exclude doctors’ offices, commercial uses, and most residential property.4
The readying rule comes from a single paragraph of Family Hospital (1977). A newly completed nursing home, fully built and equipped but not yet open to residents on the assessment date, was held exempt because it “was readying itself for its benevolent purpose.” Later court of appeals decisions declined to stretch the rule — one refused it for land bought for a future clinic; FH Healthcare refused it for a building not yet fully constructed and equipped.5
The Court has separately defined “use” as employing the physical characteristics of the property, and has described exemption questions as fact-specific, case-by-case inquiries. Both cut against a bright line in either direction.
Zoom In
The hour turned on what the statute’s words require, and on where any line falls if construction can count. Four threads stood out.
Justice Taylor opened by asking why the Court needs the readying rule at all, when its precedents have read “used exclusively for the purposes of” broadly enough to cover what is reasonably necessary to a hospital. Grounding the result in text, she suggested, avoids arguments over whether a building is 50 or 90 percent “ready.”
Hospital counsel readily agreed that the phrase looks forward and that either route wins. One justice pressed him to choose: a theory that a building under construction is currently “used” for hospital purposes is analytically different from a rule about readying, and the Court’s cases generally look at what is actually happening on the property.
A series of hypotheticals followed. Bare land with a sign announcing a future campus would likely fall short; architect’s plans submitted to the Department of Health Services likely would not, because a building approved for hospital occupancy cannot become anything else.
Another justice asked whether the readying rule had ever been applied to a building only 14 percent complete. Counsel conceded it had not, though he said other states with “used exclusively” statutes uniformly agree with the hospital.
Justice Crawford posed a hospital wing struck by lightning, evacuated, and rebuilt over six months spanning January 1. The City’s counsel answered that it would stay exempt, because hospital personnel would be present supervising the work — and later that construction workers acting under the hospital’s authority would suffice.
Another justice asked what then distinguishes a tower rising under the same supervision. The City answered that the North Tower “wasn’t even capable of being occupied.”
Justice Hagedorn asked why, after generations of tax-exempt construction, the issue is arising only now. Justice Dallet noted that the City had not assessed nine earlier construction projects on the same campus or a senior-living tower built in 2020, and another justice called the City’s treatment “a little capricious.” The City attributed the change to a 2021 review of hospital exemptions.
On remedy, the City’s counsel agreed there were no genuine issues of material fact, then argued that reversal would still require fact-finding. A justice observed that a separate trial over the completed tower’s status for 2021 through 2023 has already been tried.
The textual route Justice Taylor described is the more disciplined one, and it beats extending a one-paragraph judicial rule. But the City’s strongest argument deserves a hearing on the merits rather than a footnote. In § 70.109 the Legislature wrote “strictly construed in all instances,” and the “strict but reasonable” gloss predates that command by thirty years.
What’s Next
A decision is expected before the term closes on June 30, 2027. The reach is broad: twelve subsections of § 70.11 use the same “used exclusively” language, covering schools, churches, cemeteries, and other exempt property.
Every exempt owner pays on construction
And then sues to recover it.
The burden shifts to local taxpayers
And assessors must weigh evidence of future use.
Outright reversal, or remand?
Judgment for the hospital as it requests, or a remand for fact-finding as the dissent below proposed. Also watch how the Court treats § 70.109.
The circuit court’s pending decision on the completed tower’s 2021–2023 status will test whatever line the Court draws.6
Endnotes & Authorities · 6 citations
- Wis. Stat. §§ 70.10, 70.109, 70.11(4m)(a). Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin, Inc. v. City of Wauwatosa, No. 2023AP1432 (Wis. argued Oct. 6, 2026), on review of 2025 WI App 43, 417 Wis. 2d 629, 24 N.W.3d 601 (Colón, J., joined by Donald, P.J.; White, C.J., dissenting).
- Id. ¶¶ 1–8, 21 n.7; Wis. Dep’t of Revenue, Wisconsin Property Assessment Manual 13-59 (hospital vacant new construction). Milwaukee Cnty. Cir. Ct. (Connolly, J.).
- Children’s Hospital, 2025 WI App 43, ¶¶ 2, 12–27 (majority); id. (White, C.J., dissenting).
- Columbia Hospital Ass’n v. City of Milwaukee, 35 Wis. 2d 660, 151 N.W.2d 750 (1967); Sisters of St. Mary v. City of Madison, 89 Wis. 2d 372, 278 N.W.2d 814 (1979); Milwaukee Regional Medical Center, Inc. v. City of Wauwatosa, 2007 WI 101, 304 Wis. 2d 53, 735 N.W.2d 156.
- Family Hospital Nursing Home, Inc. v. City of Milwaukee, 78 Wis. 2d 312, 323, 254 N.W.2d 268 (1977); FH Healthcare Development, Inc. v. City of Wauwatosa, 2004 WI App 182, 276 Wis. 2d 278, 687 N.W.2d 532; First National Leasing Corp. v. City of Madison, 81 Wis. 2d 205, 260 N.W.2d 251 (1977); Deutsches Land, Inc. v. City of Glendale, 225 Wis. 2d 70, 591 N.W.2d 583 (1999).
- Characterizations of argument are drawn from the October 6, 2026 oral-argument recording.